CallTextFree estimate
Bathrooms

What a shower curb is made of, and why its tile cracks

A curb is wet on three faces and moves with the house. What it is built from, lumber or block or foam, decides whether the tile on top of it cracks.

Bathroom with an oak vanity, tiled floor and a window over the sink

Look at a tiled shower that has been in a few years and the first crack you find is almost always in the same place. It runs the length of the curb, along the top edge, hairline and dead straight. Sometimes it sits at the inside corner instead, where the curb meets the shower floor. Sometimes the tile itself has split across the middle of the step, right where a person's weight lands.

That is not a bad batch of grout and it is rarely the tile. It is a report on what is underneath — what the curb was built from, how it was fastened, and whether anyone treated its corners as corners.

What a curb is actually doing

Containment is the obvious job, and what has to happen under the floor when you take the curb away is its own subject. Less obvious is that a curb does three other things at once, and they pull against each other:

  • It is a step. People stand on it, lean on it, rest a leg on it while shaving, and sit on it. Children treat it as a bench.
  • It is usually the mounting surface for glass. A framed track screws into it. A frameless panel lands on it in a channel or on clips.
  • It is a boundary between two floors at different heights, tied to the bathroom floor on one side and to a sloped, waterproofed pan on the other.

Then the moisture. The inside face takes direct spray. The top stays wet longer than anything else in the room, because water sits there and glass drips onto it. The outside face gets splash and wet feet. The underside is dry, sealed into a cavity nobody will open again.

Wet on three faces, dry on the fourth, load on top, rigid finish bonded over the whole thing. That is the problem in one sentence.

What it gets built from

There are three assemblies in common use around here, and the choice is usually made by whoever is standing in the room on demolition day rather than by anyone looking at a drawing.

Stacked lumber

The traditional curb is dimensional lumber laid flat, two or three pieces high, fastened down through the subfloor into the framing, then wrapped in lath and mortar or in backer board and waterproofed.

It is cheap, it is fast, it trims to any height, and it holds a screw. It is also wood in a wet room. Kiln-dried stock arrives at one moisture content and starts moving toward whatever the room gives it, and wood moves across the grain far more than along it. A stack of flat-laid two-by is oriented so that nearly all of that movement is vertical — straight up into the tile bonded to its top. The same seasonal swing that opens joints in cabinet doors and hardwood works on the inside of your curb, except here it sits under a finish that cannot go anywhere.

The other weakness is fasteners. Every screw through the top or the inside face of a lumber curb is a hole punched through the waterproofing in the worst possible place.

Masonry

Brick, solid block, or a curb cast in place. Common on a slab, where there is no subfloor to fasten into and a basement bathroom rough-in has already been cut and cored into concrete anyway.

It does not rot and it does not swell with the seasons. It sits still, which is exactly what a rigid finish wants underneath it. What you trade is weight on a framed floor, and a height that arrives in unit increments plus bed joints rather than anything you can fine-tune.

And masonry is not waterproof. Block and mortar both draw water through by capillary action, and the bed joints do it faster than the units. What masonry is is dimensionally stable, which is a different property doing a different job. A block curb still needs every bit of the membrane that a lumber curb needs. It just will not fight the membrane while the seasons change.

Foam

A coated extruded-polystyrene curb, usually sold as part of a tray system and set down in thinset, with the joints banded using the same membrane material as the rest of the shower. It absorbs nothing, it moves with nothing, and there are no fasteners in it at all.

Its weaknesses are real and different. It dents if a tool box lands on it before the tile goes on. It will not hold a screw, so anything bolting to the curb needs a plan in advance. And it belongs to a system — a foam curb tied into a traditional sheet-liner pan is the same half-of-one-and-half-of-the-other build that causes trouble everywhere else in a shower.

Why the tile on top cracks

The corners are not grout joints

A curb tiled the usual way carries three pieces: inside face, top, outside face. That gives two corners running the length of the curb, plus the joint where the inside face meets the shower floor, plus a joint at each end where the curb dies into the wall.

Every one is a change of plane, a change of plane is a movement joint, and a movement joint gets sealant rather than mortar. Grout has no elasticity in tension — run a float straight through those corners and the crack is already scheduled.

This is the most common reason a curb cracks, and it is a sequencing decision. Masking the corners, letting the field cure and coming back another day with a sealant gun is two trips instead of one.

The curb moves and the tile does not

A lumber curb is fastened to the floor structure and rides every deflection the joists give it, while the tile bridging its top edge is a stiff plate that would rather not bend. A fresh mortar bed shrinks as it cures. A wet stack of lumber swells. Neither movement is large. Neither needs to be — tile fails at hairline scale.

The tile is hollow where it needs to be solid

The top of a curb is the last piece set in a shower, usually by whoever is left at the end of the day, onto thinset that has been open a while. Spot-bond it — a dab at each corner and one in the middle — and you have a rigid plate with voids under it, in the one place in the room where a heel lands with a person's full weight behind it.

Tap along the top of a cracked curb with a knuckle. It usually sounds hollow before it sounds solid, and it sounds hollow exactly where the crack is. Curbs also take impacts nothing else in the room takes — a dropped bottle, a door swung too hard, a stepladder foot during a repaint. A bedded tile absorbs those. A hollow one splits.

Waterproofing three faces and two ends

The membrane leaves the shower floor, climbs the inside face, crosses the top and comes down the outside past the finished bathroom floor, without a break anywhere in that run — then does the same around both ends, where the curb returns into a tiled wall. That is a lot of corners in a small object, which puts it in the same argument as everything else behind the tile: the flat field is easy, and the transitions are where water gets out.

Three details decide whether a curb is waterproofed or just painted:

  1. Nothing penetrates the wet side. On a traditional pan-liner build the liner is draped over the curb and fastened only on the outside face, above any level water could reach. Lath goes on the same way. A staple through the top or the inside face of a curb liner is a hole in the bottom of a bucket.
  2. The corners are preformed, not improvised. Every membrane manufacturer sells dam corners and outside corners for exactly this, because a folded corner made up on site by hand is the piece most likely to be short.
  3. The top falls back into the shower. Pitched slightly toward the inside, a curb top sends the water sitting on it back to the drain. Set flat and finished by eye, it runs the other way, and you get a dark line on the bathroom floor the length of the shower.

Glass, and the holes people drill in it

The wettest horizontal surface in the room is also where a lot of enclosures want their fasteners. Drilling a curb top for a bottom track or a panel clip puts holes through the membrane exactly where water sits longest.

There are better arrangements, and which ones are available depends on whether the enclosure is framed or frameless. Wall-mounted hinges and a header carry the load in the walls instead. A fixed panel can often be clamped on the outside face, on the dry side of the dam, rather than through the top. Where a hole in the curb genuinely cannot be avoided, it goes on the outside third, gets bedded in sealant rather than dry-set, and never goes into foam without a solid insert planned before the curb is built. None of this can be added afterwards. Once the tile is on, the curb is closed.

Height, width, and the case for a one-piece cap

A curb has two heights and only one is the one you feel. The shower floor falls to the drain, so the finished floor at the inside of the curb is the high point of the pan, while the bathroom floor on the other side is flat. Measure from the wrong side and the step you drew is not the step you get.

Width matters more than people expect. The top has to carry the tile, a sealant joint at each corner, and whatever the glass lands on. Built narrow to save floor space, it leaves nothing to work with and the enclosure hangs off its outside edge.

The best single move on a curb is a one-piece cap: stone, quartz or porcelain slab cut to the full width and run the length of the curb in one piece. It deletes both top corner joints — the two most likely to crack — and replaces them with a continuous surface that sheds water. It still needs sealant where the cap meets the tiled faces and where it dies into the wall, but those joints now sit in flat planes rather than on the arris, the sharp edge where two surfaces meet. A bead laid in a flat plane has depth behind it and room to stretch; a bead folded over an arris is a thin skin on a sharp edge, and it is the first thing in a shower to peel. Look through the showers in our project gallery and the capped curbs are the ones with no joint anywhere along the top.

A lower step, or eventually no step at all, is a framing conversation rather than a tile one — the same one behind building in accessibility before you need it.

Where this lands in a quote

You will not find a line called "curb" with a meaningful number beside it. In materials it is almost nothing — some lumber or a foam blank, a bit of membrane, three pieces of tile.

We do not publish our own prices, for the reason we give everywhere: a number written before anyone has seen your bathroom is a guess. What we can point at is independent research on this market. Angi's Indianapolis bathroom cost research and published Greater Indianapolis contractor cost guides put a typical bathroom at around $10,000, with most landing roughly between $5,700 and $14,700.

The curb is a rounding error inside that. The repair is not. A crack on top of a curb is not something you grout over — getting to it means the enclosure off, tile off three planes, finding out what the membrane has been doing in the dark, and building the shower back. That is most of a shower, priced twice.

The short version

A curb is small, it is the least considered object in the bathroom, and it decides how the shower ages. Three questions tell you what you are getting:

  • What is it built from, and does that material belong to the same system as the pan?
  • Are the corners along its length grouted, or sealed?
  • Does anything penetrate the top or the inside face, and if so, what handles the waterproofing there?

Anyone who has built showers properly answers all three immediately, and answers them in terms of the assembly rather than the brand. On our own jobs the curb is built and waterproofed in the stage before any finish material reaches the site, which is also the last moment it can be inspected without a demolition bar. That sequence is the one set out on the bathroom remodeling page: strip out, then the structure and the membrane, then everything you can see.

If yours is already cracked and you want to know whether it is the grout or the thing underneath, ask us to come and look. A knuckle and a few minutes is usually enough to tell.

Keep reading

Want this looked at in your house?

A free walkthrough, measurements taken on site, and a written estimate with materials and labor itemized. No sales visit unless you ask for one.